News & Commentary

Iranian Justice: The stoning of Soraya M

Originally published in The Examiner

Independent Women's Forum | 9/5/08 5:05 PM

Those who want to know the truth about Iranian justice must see Cyrus Nowrasteh's gripping new feature film "The Stoning of Soraya M."

The film - based on the book written by Friedounce Sahebjam and debuting today at the Toronto International Film Festival - depicts the true life story of Soraya M, an Iranian woman falsely accused of adultery.

She was then sentenced to death by stoning so that her husband would be free to marry a 14-year old. Partially buried in the ground, she was savagely stoned to death by a mob of men that included her own father, husband, and two of her sons.

Her story continues to haunt all of us who have already seen the film. Anyone who questions the danger that is Iran must see this film and witness the barbaric nature of radical, fundamentalist Islamic "justice."

Islamists target those who question their extreme agenda and they close their societies to dissent. Freedom House, a nonprofit group dedicated to advancing liberty worldwide, reports that since 2000, the Iranian judiciary "closed more than 100 reformist newspapers and jailed hundreds of liberal journalists and activists, while security forces cracked down on the ensuing student protests."

The so-called Council of Guardians blocked any attempts at liberalization. Tehran Mayor Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who won the presidency in 2005, may be best known to Americans for his incendiary rhetoric and threats against Israel, but Iranians know him for appointing as top ministers "hard-liners who have been implicated directly in the extrajudicial killings of dissidents and other egregious human rights abuses," adds Freedom House.

Unfortunately, according to the U.S. Department of State, last year "The government's poor human rights record worsened, and it continued to commit numerous, serious abuses. The government severely limited citizens' right to change their government peacefully through free and fair elections.

There were reports of unjust executions after unfair trials. Security forces committed acts of politically motivated abductions; torture and severe officially sanctioned punishments, including death by stoning; amputation; flogging; and excessive use of force against and imprisonment of demonstrators."

There is no religious freedom in Iran. The State Department reports that "Government rhetoric and actions created a threatening atmosphere for nearly all non-Shi'a religious groups, most notably for Baha'is, as well as Sufi Muslims, evangelical Christians, and members of the Jewish community."

Although more widely educated than men, women's professional opportunities are limited: They are barred from serving as judges, discouraged from seeking elected office, and face rampant discrimination.

Under Shariah, or Islamic, law, which Ahmadinejad's has more strictly enforced, women are segregated and forced to conform to a strict dress code. They also do not have equal rights in the laws pertaining to divorce, inheritance and child custody.

A presidential adviser on women's issues, Zahra Shojaie, once said the stoning of adulterers was permissible "to defend the inviolability of the family." This chilling policy is displayed in the movie "The Stoning of Soraya M." Thankfully, Iran's judiciary recently suspended several stoning sentences and submitted legislation to parliament to end stoning.

Just as women fought for the vote in America, women are fighting for their rights as citizens and human beings in Iran. But they take far greater risks and face far greater punishments. "Dozens of women's rights advocates were arrested in 2007 for endangering national security and sentenced to prison terms," according to Freedom House.

Obviously, the U.S. government's influence over Iran is limited. Washington's overriding concern at present is ending Tehran's nuclear program. But U.S. officials can help expose Iran's flagrant violations of human rights.

As Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice stated at an Independent Women's Forum event in 2006, "When we talk about respect for women, we are referring to a moral truth. Women are free by nature, equal in dignity and entitled to the same rights, the same protections and the same opportunities as men." And that includes in Iran.

But promoting freedom is not just the responsibility of our government. It is our responsibility too. Films like "The Stoning of Sorya M" play a critical role in educating and enraging people about women's human rights. We have to turn that knowledge and anger into action.

A year ago, IWF held a conference with pro-democracy Iranian women living in Iran to assist them with their self-described goal of supporting democratic governance and reform in Iran, particularly women's human rights.

All of the participants in the IWF conference were part of a grassroots movement called the "One Million Signatures" campaign gathering signatures of one million Iranians demanding the end of legal discrimination against women.

The government has harassed and jailed many of the activists involved, but they continue to press for their basic rights as human beings. They ask for America's support in publicizing their efforts, posting their articles on the Web, writing Iranian officials to request fair and equal treatment for women - especially arrested activists - and sharing the experiences of women's movements in other nations.

Scripture tells us that to whom much is given, much is expected. Certainly that is true when it comes to liberty. America has given us much. Let us do whatever we can to share the same bountiful freedoms and opportunities with others.

As Secretary Rice observed at IWF's Woman of Valor Award dinner two years ago: "You don't have to impose democracy; you have to impose tyranny. Democracy lives and breathes, liberty lives and breathes, in the heart of every human being."

Michelle D. Bernard is the president and chief executive officer of the Independent Women's Forum and an MSNBC policy analyst

11 Comments

Ruby Smith | September 11, 2008, 4:00pm | #

I believe that this is a true picture of Islam as far as it goes, but Islam is far more heinous than this. And just think, the Democrats in the United States wants to elect an Islamic practitioner to the presidency of this nation.

Isn't ignorance just grand?

Alisha Dale | September 12, 2008, 8:39am | #

I am astounded by the silence of the feminist movement on this issue! American women are fooling ourselves if we think this is just something that happens "over there" and not "here" on American soil. Ask yourself how many news stories we've heard in the last three years of honour killings and forced marriages IN AMERICA. The American public as a whole, both men and women, need to wake up to the fact that we've got to start progressive campaigning to end this mindset in whatever form it presents itself be it religious or societal. There simply is no defense for this kind of behavior. IT IS WRONG ON EVERY LEVEL!!! Period, end of story.

mary jane rose | September 12, 2008, 1:00pm | #

The American feminists are only worried about hating Candidate Palin because she has 5 children and does not belive in abortion. They keep quiet about violence and injustice to our sisters abroad. They need to step to the plate and be counted. They are only interested in Celebrity Feminists. Feminsts in name only without grit or character.

Leila | September 16, 2008, 8:41am | #

To Ruby Smith above,

You are the ignorant one. Barack Obama is not an Islamic practitioner. I don't know where you are getting your information from.

In regards to Islam, those who practice it the right way are not fundamentalists. While it's true that fundamentalists exist and should be done away with, they do not represent true Muslims because Islam does not support their behavior, just like Christianity does not support the behavior of our current murderous President Bush. Real Christians do not support the Bush administration.

In any case, like I said before, you are the ignorant one.

suzanne small | September 20, 2008, 7:10pm | #

To Ruby Smith and all,
I saw the movie "The Stoning" at the Toronto Film Festival. It was a "full house" and there wasn't a dry eye when it was over. It was a beautifully crafted movie and hopefully will be showing in movie houses everywhere as it should be seen by everyone on the planet. Unfortunately it won't be shown in Muslim countries as they don't like to be threatened by the truth. Ruby, don't stoop to the same level by propagating the lie that Barack Obama is a Muslim. If anyone checks the facts, they will find this to be clearly untrue. He is and always was a Christian and most people know this to be true.. This kind of distortion of the truth only makes you look like a fool. It also does nothing to help advance the cause of protecting innocent women in Muslim extremist regions from being treated worse than animals.

An Iranian-American Youth | September 21, 2008, 1:06pm | #

Respectfully, I would like to respond to Ruby Smith's comment. Islam isn't 'heinous.' It has been manipulated by power hungry mullahs. Keep in mind, so have a few other prominent religions in the past. They've misconstrued the Quran's texts and unfortunately poor & ignorant persons observe these translations believing that they are true. As a matter of fact, during the Islamic Revolution in Iran more than 50% of the population was below the poverty line. Furthermore, Barack Obama is a practicing Christian whose father was a Muslim Kenyan. Regardless of this, Islam is a religion rooted in pacifism and tolerance. Ma'm, may I please remind you that Islam was the first of all major monotheistic religions to clearly state that other monotheistic faiths had to be tolerated. Similar to how ignorant persons in Middle East are susceptible to being manipulated, so are ignorant persons in the U.S. susceptible to becoming unsoundly bigoted.

Rex | March 9, 2009, 4:41pm | #

In regard to the idea that "Islam was the first of all major monotheistic religions to clearly state that other monotheistic faiths had to be tolerated"; this is a historical falsehood. First "tolerance" is a demeaning word, it connotes a superior/inferior relationship between two religions. To the fact- Muhammad did not decree that the "People of the Book" (Christians, Jews) that resided in Dar al Islam (The house of Islam) were equals. They were in fact not equal, but as a practical matter, were to be left alone by practitioners of Islam under the conditions that they accepted they were inferior, and that they made their special tax payments (jizya) to the local tribal leaders. It was only a crime to kill a christian or jew if they had not resisted their status (or if they had not personally offended a muslim as judged by the local islamic leaders). It is true that religions have been adulterated in the past- the question for Islam is when they will have their reformation and move out of the dark ages, if it is even possible.

Mariam Zahrae | April 21, 2009, 12:40pm | #

Ruby,
How dare you?!? It's absurdly ironic that you sit there and speak of ignorance. I am an Iranian-American Muslim woman and although I am ashamed at the tyrannical government that runs my country, I am a proud Muslim. Islam is not about stonings and punishments, it's about love of your fellow human. Islam in Iran and other similar nations is not practiced as it should be by the government, in fact it is not practiced at all. What is practiced is barbarianism under the pretext of Islam. I am ashamed at the ignorance that my fellow Americans exhibit towards Islam. You will find, perhaps shockingly, that Islam is incredibly similar to Christianity and Judaism. So for the your own benefit as well as that of your country's, turn off the T.V. and go read a book. Think before you speak and stop assuming that you are learned on a subject when you do not know the first thing about it. I am sickened by the thought that someone could even think to make a comment like that without any prior knowledge.

Karen | May 28, 2009, 5:46pm | #

Leila, you should you probably read the Bible agains, as you call "real christians" non-supporters of Bush.

Sumit Aggarwal | June 20, 2009, 1:58pm | #

This article is far from being true. Its a movie propagandist in nature and was not directed with reform or awareness in mind. Check my blog for full details http://sumit-aggarwal.blogspot.com/

RubyM | October 8, 2009, 4:24pm | #

First off, ALL religion is evil and misogynist. I left the Catholic church at 13 because of the racist, misogynist, anti-poor attitudes. Pro-choice IS pro-life! Men are just frightened of women and they always will be. How do they control women? By telling them to be obedient and making them have children. The Iranian revolution is a prime example of not only ideological barbarism, but INSANE religiosity that ANY country can fall into regardless of major religion. I don't mid if your a Muslim, Jew, or observant Christian, but every time I see a woman in a hijab or wearing ugly, baggy dresses and wigs and are forced to walk behind men I just get crazy! And yes, I am a liberal but DON'T support Palestine or Israel, and never have. Free the women of Iran! Free Iran! Kill Niloufar Ebtekar! Kill Ahmadinejad (who by the way is actually Jewish)!

Comment on this article: